Genre

Hymn

8.7
Judy Collins

Amazing Grace

Judy Collins didn't write a note of it, produce a hook onto it, or add a single instrument — and her 1970 a cappella 'Amazing Grace' still became a transatlantic hit. The whole achievement is in what she chose not to do.

Read review →
8.5
George Beverly Shea

How Great Thou Art

George Beverly Shea didn't write a word of 'How Great Thou Art' -- he just sang it roughly a hundred times over one sixteen-week crusade until an obscure translated hymn became a standard.

Read review →
8.8
Carrie Underwood

How Great Thou Art

Carrie Underwood and Vince Gill's 2011 televised duet went viral within days -- and Underwood liked the moment enough to record the hymn again, a decade later, on her own terms.

Read review →
9.0
Elvis Presley

How Great Thou Art

Elvis Presley's first competitive Grammy win, out of fourteen nominations across his career, came for a gospel record -- and 'How Great Thou Art' is the reason why.

Read review →
9.0
Mahalia Jackson

It Is Well with My Soul

Mahalia Jackson's 1968 recording treats Horatio Spafford's grief-forged hymn with the same restraint Spafford's own words ask for -- and lets the power stay in reserve until the very end.

Read review →